Two of the most sought-after natural stone slabs for kitchen installations are granite countertops and marble countertops. Both surfaces offer various color and texture choices, and these natural stone materials are popular picks since they increase property value, too. Many homeowners select granite countertops for their modern or traditional design aesthetic, while others opt for marble because of its luxurious looks.
But, how do you know when to choose one countertop over the other? It really comes down to personal design preference, durability, maintenance needs, and cost. This straightforward guide will point out the differences and advantages of granite countertops and marble countertops so that you can make the best-informed decision for your next kitchen project.
Appearance
One reason why homeowners go gaga for granite countertops is because of their many colors, patterns, and variations. Choose from white granite, beige, brown, copper, pink, black granite, and everything in between. Some slabs feature subtler specks, while others include a range of unique streaks, so it?s key to select a specific slab since no two patterns are the same. Just remember that unusual colors like red or blue may become unpopular over time and attract a smaller niche of potential homebuyers.
Colonial White GraniteLegendary in its own right, marble is easily recognizable thanks to its beautiful veining and timeless appearance. With unique patterns and variations, each slab of marble is one-of-a-kind and naturally becomes the centerpiece of any design. The most common marble colors are white and cream, but tan, brown, black, and gray are also available. Vein colors range from white and cream to gold and gray, and patterns can be as fine as thin lines or as bold as sweeping movements.
Carrara marble, priced similarly to granite, is the most common type. In contrast, Calacatta marble stands out with its thicker veining, more luxurious appearance, and higher cost. Emperador marble features various shades of brown, whereas Crema Marfil brightens spaces with its beige or yellowish hues.
One feature that?s familiar for both products is the surface finishes. Granite and marble come in polished, honed, leather, and brushed finishes. Which one you choose depends on your desire for a shiny, matte, or textured look and feel to go with your modern, farmhouse, rustic, or traditional kitchen design. Selecting the right countertop finish can dramatically influence the overall look and maintenance requirements of your space.
Durability
Granite is considered one of the most durable natural stone countertops due to its heat resistance, which helps prevent cracks and chips even when hot pots or pans are placed directly on it. It also resists scratches better than marble, though it can still potentially etch. Usually, spills can be wiped away easily on granite, but it?s advisable to clean counters promptly to prevent staining of the porous surface.
Calacatta MarbleMany see marble as delicate yet luxurious. However, it?s actually more durable, resisting cracks and chips. The heat-resistant stone can withstand temperatures up to 350癋, but for hotter cooking, a trivet is necessary.
However, marble has some drawbacks such as susceptibility to scratching and staining. Since it is a softer stone, it can easily be etched, so always use a cutting board when chopping or cutting food. Additionally, acidic foods like tomatoes, lemons, and wine, as well as acidic cleaners, can cause etching. To prevent stains, promptly wipe up any spills from food, drinks, or water spots.
Maintenance
These stone countertops can be long-lasting with proper care and attention. When it comes to maintenance, granite countertops and marble both require resealing, but how often may be determined by the surface type and how much use your kitchen gets.
Granite should be sealed roughly every two years to help resist moisture. If minor damage like scratches occurs, it can be repaired with a color-matching epoxy, but leave larger cracks to the professionals. Clean granite regularly with mild soap and water, and avoid abrasive cleaners, as they can cause scratches and dull the finish. Quickly wipe up spills to prevent stains, especially oil-based liquids, which stain more easily. With these care tips, granite can truly last a lifetime.
White Spring GraniteMarble should be sealed every six months to a year. While sealing helps prevent stains, it doesn?t protect against etching. For cleaning, use a pH-neutral cleaner or one made for natural stone. Because marble is more porous than granite, promptly wiping up spills will prevent staining and etching. Additionally, a special detergent is necessary to effectively remove stains from this luxurious surface. Following these maintenance tips will help marble last a long time, though it may show more wear than granite over time.
Price
Both granite and marble are considered more expensive countertop options. Granite is generally less costly, at about three-fifths the price of marble. On average, granite costs between $40 and $100 per square foot, while marble ranges from $50 to $150 per square foot.
However, with pricing fluctuations and other factors, prices can vary. The type, size, labor, and additional treatments all influence the cost. For example, higher-quality stone or rarer colors of granite, or types of marble like Calacatta, tend to be more expensive. Certain shapes and larger slabs for either material can increase the price, but smaller pieces or tiles offer a more budget-friendly option. The complexity of the installation and the amount of labor involved also contribute to the overall cost. Finally, if manufacturers apply treatments such as finishes that enhance stain or etching resistance, you?ll pay more upfront for a surface that’s easier to maintain.
Fantasy White MarbleWhen comparing granite and marble, both natural stone countertops are beautiful choices, but granite has the edge regarding durability and easier maintenance. While these tips can help you decide which surface suits your lifestyle, you might also consider using an online marble or granite visualizer to see how each option looks in your space.
Our countertops selections include granite, marble, travertine, limestone, slate, and Q Premium Natural Quartz options in shiny and matte finishes. Use the MSI Countertop Selection Guide to get some ideas for your kitchen. You can also chat online with our team right now to learn where to buy countertops. You can also visit an MSI showroom near you, or contact an authorized MSI retailer in your area.
Read More Granite Compared to Other Natural Stone Countertops
Granite, Quartz or Quartzite? Countertop Slab Materials in a Nutshell
Slate, Marble, Granite and Quartzite: 5 Natural Stone Tile Ideas
Should You Choose Marble or Granite Countertops?